Description

PEN1502 Assignment 1 Semester 1 | Due 20 March 2025. All questions answered. INSTRUCTIONS: Carefully read the provided case study below, then answer the following questions that apply to the case study! The case study involves a man named John Z., currently serving time on Death Row for the vicious murders of two individuals. Mr. Z is being evaluated for his competency to be executed, which includes his ability to understand the crimes he committed, the moral implications of those crimes, the fact that he is physically confined to Death Row, the fact that his impending death is imminent, the fact that death is permanent and the reason he is being executed (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). According to records, Mr. Z is the middle child of three children and his parents divorced when he was four years old (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). His mother remarried when he was approximately six years old and he did not have any significant contact with his biological father, who passed away about fifteen years ago (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). Mr. Z’s mother stated that he was well adjusted throughout early childhood and did not display behavioral issues until around the age of twelve (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). Although there are numerous correlates to take into consideration, there was no reference as to whether or not Mr. Z was sexually, mentally, or physically abused as a child, whether he suffered from bullying as a child, and whether or not he associated with other deviants. The criminal behavior in which Mr. Z took place involved the murder of a man that he had a homosexual relationship with and the murder of another unknown individual. Based on Mr. Z’s long history of behavior issues as a child, sexual promiscuity, extensive history of family and personal mental health issues, and long-lasting and serious drug dependency, it is evident that multiple factors may have contributed to his criminal actions. His troubled upbringing, marked by instability and psychological distress, likely played a role in shaping his behavior. Additionally, his struggles with substance abuse may have impaired his judgment and heightened aggressive tendencies. The combination of these elements suggests that Mr. Z’s actions were influenced not only by personal relationships but also by deep-seated psychological and environmental factors. Understanding these complexities is crucial in assessing his culpability and potential avenues for rehabilitation. Answer the following questions pertains to the extract above: QUESTION 1 1.1 What theories of punishment (e.g., retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, incapacitation) justify John Z.’s death sentence? 1.2 Does John Z.’s punishment align with the principle of proportionality in sentencing? Explain how. 1.3 Is the death penalty the most appropriate form of punishment for John z., or would life imprisonment be a more just alternative? Provide justifications, 1.4 What are the potential moral and ethical concerns surrounding John Z.’s execution? 25 Marks QUESTION 2 2.1 Does the death penalty in cases like John Z.’s serve as an effective deterrent to violent crime? Critically explain how. 2.2 Explain, how John Z.’s case contributes to the debate on whether capital punishment reduces homicide rates? 2.3 Are there alternative sentencing options that could achieve the same deterrent effect as the death penalty?, Discuss those alternatives. 2.4 Share your opinion on whether the death penalty can reduce the crime rate in South Africa if brought back. 25 Marks Total Marks: 50

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

Description

PEN1502 Assignment 1 Semester 1 | Due 20 March 2025. All questions answered. INSTRUCTIONS: Carefully read the provided case study below, then answer the following questions that apply to the case study! The case study involves a man named John Z., currently serving time on Death Row for the vicious murders of two individuals. Mr. Z is being evaluated for his competency to be executed, which includes his ability to understand the crimes he committed, the moral implications of those crimes, the fact that he is physically confined to Death Row, the fact that his impending death is imminent, the fact that death is permanent and the reason he is being executed (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). According to records, Mr. Z is the middle child of three children and his parents divorced when he was four years old (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). His mother remarried when he was approximately six years old and he did not have any significant contact with his biological father, who passed away about fifteen years ago (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). Mr. Z’s mother stated that he was well adjusted throughout early childhood and did not display behavioral issues until around the age of twelve (Heilbrun, Marczyk, & DeMatteo, 2002). Although there are numerous correlates to take into consideration, there was no reference as to whether or not Mr. Z was sexually, mentally, or physically abused as a child, whether he suffered from bullying as a child, and whether or not he associated with other deviants. The criminal behavior in which Mr. Z took place involved the murder of a man that he had a homosexual relationship with and the murder of another unknown individual. Based on Mr. Z’s long history of behavior issues as a child, sexual promiscuity, extensive history of family and personal mental health issues, and long-lasting and serious drug dependency, it is evident that multiple factors may have contributed to his criminal actions. His troubled upbringing, marked by instability and psychological distress, likely played a role in shaping his behavior. Additionally, his struggles with substance abuse may have impaired his judgment and heightened aggressive tendencies. The combination of these elements suggests that Mr. Z’s actions were influenced not only by personal relationships but also by deep-seated psychological and environmental factors. Understanding these complexities is crucial in assessing his culpability and potential avenues for rehabilitation. Answer the following questions pertains to the extract above: QUESTION 1 1.1 What theories of punishment (e.g., retribution, deterrence, rehabilitation, incapacitation) justify John Z.’s death sentence? 1.2 Does John Z.’s punishment align with the principle of proportionality in sentencing? Explain how. 1.3 Is the death penalty the most appropriate form of punishment for John z., or would life imprisonment be a more just alternative? Provide justifications, 1.4 What are the potential moral and ethical concerns surrounding John Z.’s execution? 25 Marks QUESTION 2 2.1 Does the death penalty in cases like John Z.’s serve as an effective deterrent to violent crime? Critically explain how. 2.2 Explain, how John Z.’s case contributes to the debate on whether capital punishment reduces homicide rates? 2.3 Are there alternative sentencing options that could achieve the same deterrent effect as the death penalty?, Discuss those alternatives. 2.4 Share your opinion on whether the death penalty can reduce the crime rate in South Africa if brought back. 25 Marks Total Marks: 50

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

37
    37
    Your Shopping Cart
    CMY1501 ASSIGNMENT 01 SOLUTIONS SEMESTER 1 2024
    R50.00
    CMY3705 Assignment
    CMY3705 ASSIGNMENT 1 SEMESTER 1 2025 - FULLY ANSWERED
    Seller:

    The Smart Slacker

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    ESC3701 Assignment 2
    ESC3701 Assignment 2 2025 - May 2025
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R60.00
    R60.00
    CIC2601 Assignment 3
    CIC2601 Assignment 3 Due 2 August 2024
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    HFL1501 Assignment 3 (Answers) Due 17th April 2024
    R50.00
    AED3701 Assignment 4 Memo | Due 8 September 2025
    AED3701 Assignment 4 Memo | Due 8 September 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    HRD3701 ASSIGNMENT 2 SEMESTER 2 2025 - FULLY ANSWERED (DUE 29 AUGUST 2025)
    R100.00
    SCW2601 Assignment 2 Semester 1 Memo | Due 17 April 2025
    R100.00
    COM1512 ASSIGNMENT 1 SEMESTER 1 2025 - FULLY ANSWERED
    COM1512 ASSIGNMENT 1 SEMESTER 1 2025 - FULLY ANSWERED
    Seller:

    The Smart Slacker

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    TRL3706 Assignment 1 Semester 1 | Due 14 March 2025
    TRL3706 Assignment 1 Semester 1 | Due 14 March 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    THL3703 PORTFOLIO SEMESTER 2 2025 - FULLY ANSWERED (DUE 15 OCTOBER 2025)
    R60.00
    FAC2601 Assignment 5 Due May June 2024
    FAC2601 Assignment 5 Due May June 2024
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R60.00
    R60.00
    ENG2601 Assignment 2 Memo | Due 24 June 2025
    ENG2601 Assignment 2 Memo | Due 24 June 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    AFK1503 Werkopdrag 2 Memo | Due 25 Junie 2025
    AFK1503 Werkopdrag 2 Memo | Due 25 Junie 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    LJU4804 October/November 2024 | Due 18 October 2024
    LJU4804 October/November 2024 | Due 18 October 2024
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    SUS1501 Assignment 7 Due 22 April 2024
    SUS1501 Assignment 7 Due 22 April 2024
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    FOR3703 May/June Exam 2025 - Due 30 May 2025
    FOR3703 May/June Exam 2025 - Due 30 May 2025
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R80.00
    R80.00
    ENG1517 Assignment 2 2025 Due 26 June 2025
    ENG1517 Assignment 2 2025 Due 26 June 2025
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    CPR3701 ASSIGNMENT 1 SEMESTER 1 2025
    CPR3701 ASSIGNMENT 1 SEMESTER 1 2025
    Seller:

    The Smart Slacker

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    RDF2601 Assignment 2 Memo | Due 13 May 2025
    RDF2601 Assignment 2 Memo | Due 13 May 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    PRO4801 Assignment 3 Memo
    PRO4801 Assignment 3 Memo | Due 8 September 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    BSW3702 Assignment 3 (Portfolio) 2024 | Due 1 October 2024
    R80.00
    HSY1511 Assignment 2 Semester 1 2024
    HSY1511 Assignment 2 Semester 1 2024
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    FUR2601 Assignment 2 For Semester 2 2022 (Solutions)
    FUR2601 Assignment 2 For Semester 2 2022 (Solutions)
    Seller:

    Mbali Law Tutor

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    HED4812 Assignment 4 2024 | Due 30 August 2024
    HED4812 Assignment 4 2024 | Due 30 August 2024
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    AFK2603 Assignment 1 (Quiz) Semester 1 Memo | Due 30 April 2025
    R100.00
    OTE2601: The No1 Exam Pack for this module
    OTE2601: The No1 Exam Pack for this module
    Seller:

    The Graduate

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    DPR1503 Assignment 3 Semester 1 Memo | Due 25 April 2025
    R100.00
    TRL3702 Assignment 1
    TRL3702 ASSIGNMENT 1 SEMESTER 1 2025
    Seller:

    The Smart Slacker

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00
    LPL4802 Portfolio Semester 2 Due 27 October 2023
    LPL4802 Portfolio Semester 2 Due 27 October 2023
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R60.00
    R60.00
    CUS3701 Assignment 1 Quiz 100% Due 3 May 2024
    CUS3701 Assignment 1 Quiz 100% Due 3 May 2024
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    ECS1601 Assignment 8 Due 12 November 2024 (100%)
    ECS1601 Assignment 8 Due 12 November 2024 (100%)
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    TPS2601 Assignment 2
    TPS2601 Assignment 2 Due 25 july 2024
    Seller:

    Unisian

    Price: R50.00
    R50.00
    MIP2601 Assignment 2 Memo | Due 11 June 2025
    MIP2601 Assignment 2 Memo | Due 11 June 2025
    Seller:

    Aimark94

    Price: R100.00
    R100.00